Skip to content

Comments on “Individual external dose monitoring of all citizens of Date City by passive dosimeter 5 to 51 months after the Fukushima NPP accident (series): 1. Comparison of individual dose with ambient dose rate monitored by aircraft surveys.” via arXiv

Masaki OshikawaYutaka HamaokaKyo KageuraShin-ichi KurokawaJun MakinoYoh Tanimoto(Submitted on 31 Jan 2020)


(12) In the Conclusion section, the authors write “it is possible to predict the external exposure dose received by each individual based on the aircraft monitoring data”. As we pointed out above, individual fluctuations of the coefficient are not taken into account in drawing such a conclusion. The conclusion of this paper cannot be a basis of radiological protection.
To summarize all the issues (1)–(12) above, the treatment of data in the paper does not satisfy the minimum standard required for scientific papers. For instance, it is even unclear whether the main conclusion “c = 0.15” represents the average or the median of the actual data, and the number of samples excluded as outliers is not specified. Given that the exposure dose is known to follow the log-normal distribution, there should be no need
to exclude part of the samples as outliers if the logarithm is taken in the first place. As observed in Fig. 4, it is highly likely that c is underestimated because samples with high dose exposure are excluded. The authors of this paper analyzed the logarithm of exposure in other papers [8][4]. It is necessary to explain why this paper did not do so. For the purpose
of radiological protection, the large variation of the individual doses is important, and it is inappropriate just to use the median or the average. Furthermore, c should depend on the age and lifestyles of participants, but the authors did not take that into account. Moreover, although they state “[T]hese results show that coarse-grained airborne data can be a useful
estimator for predicting the individual doses of residents living in contaminated areas” in Section 4, they do not give any information that shows the goodness-of-fit. We note that, while one of us (S. K.) has written a comment [9] concerning the subsequent paper [10], this Letter addresses separate issues on a different paper [1].

We thank Ms. Akemi Shima for providing us with the public documents obtained through her Freedom of Information requests.
Some of the issues pointed out in this Letter were discussed in Refs. [11, 12, 13], in the Japanese magazine KAGAKU. This Letter is composed as an original article in English, with a permission of the publisher of KAGAKU (Iwanami Shoten, Publishers). We also thank the KAGAKU Editorial Office for opportunities to discuss this work.

Read more.

Posted in *English.

Tagged with , , , , , , .

29 Responses

Stay in touch with the conversation, subscribe to the RSS feed for comments on this post.

  1. CS0-002 exam questions says

    DumpsTool has introduced the most useful CompTIA CySA+ CS0-002 PDF Dumps that assure your success in the CS0-002 exam questions. This CS0-002 Dumps PDF carry practice questions that give you the true picture of the actual CompTIA CySA+ CS0-002 exam questions scenario because our CompTIA CySA+ Certification Exam (CS0-002) CS0-002 exam dumps are created this way. Now, you can prepare real CS0-002 exam questions this is how you will know how to handle the CS0-002 exam dumps pressure and time constraints on the exam.

  2. Noida Escorts Service says

    My name is Rita I am available in Gurgaon and you can know the more information in this aspect, her to know the above features regarded my services you can find lots of things in this aspect.

  3. dark web links says

    Well, the answer is not so simple. You see, the reason why it isn’t so simple is that there are many grey areas when it comes to this particular issue.

  4. says

    Thanks for such a valuable post. I am waiting for your next post, I have enjoyed a lot reading this post keep it up.

  5. says

    Your blog is really nice. Its sound really good

  6. says

    Thank you for sharing this useful article. Keep it up! Regards!

  7. says

    All your hard work is much appreciated your thoughts. This content data gives truly quality and unique information. I’m definitely going to look into it. Really very beneficial tips are provided here and, Thank you so much. Keep up the good works.

  8. 더킹카지노 says

    I have read this put up and if I may I desire to recommend
    you some interesting things or tips. Maybe you can write next articles regarding this
    article. I wish to learn more issues approximately it!

  9. says

    Fairly certain he will have a good read. Thank you for sharing!

  10. says

    Found your post interesting to read. I can’t wait to see your post soon. Good Luck for the upcoming update. This article is really very interesting and effective.

  11. 바둑이사이트넷 says

    I really enjoy your web’s topic. Very creative and friendly for users. Definitely bookmark this and follow it everyday.

  12. says

    Way cool, some valid points! I appreciate you making this article available, the rest of the site is also high quality. Have a fun. 파칭코

  13. says

    Hi! this is often nice article you shared with great information. Thanks for giving such an exquisite informative information. 슬롯머신777사이트

  14. says

    Superb Very creative Superior work. LOVE IT!! 카지노사이트프로

  15. says

    I think this is a real great blog article. enjoy reading this! 카지노사이트

  16. says

    Just desire to say your article is as surprising. The clearness in your post is simply great and i can assume you are an expert on this subject. 카지노사이트

  17. avg driver updater crack says

    AVG Driver Updater Crack is an interactive application for updating and installing drivers with a lot of hassle and wasted time. Drivers are the primary source of lag, freezing, or not achieving the correct results we are looking for as driver updates provide new enhancements, fixes, and more fixing issues and bugs. avg driver updater crack

  18. تصليح ثلاجات حولي says

    Yes, I completely agree with this article, and all I have to say is that it is a very nice and interesting article. I’ll make an effort to read your blog more frequently.

  19. alheba jabal says

    I do recommend this article to my classmates particularly if they are dealing with presenting technical skill. However,

  20. الهيبة جبل الجزء الخامس 6 says

    This is the first time I’ve come across a blog that is both useful and educational. Thank you for keeping us informed.

  21. Kurulus Osman 67 says

    Good post
    Thank you

  22. nbayoungboy says

    Great this site and its information is very well.nbayoungboymerchThanks for sharing information such a great another people guide.

  23. popsmokemerchshop says

    I feel extremely cheerful to have seen your post. I found the most beautiful and fascinating one. I am really extremely glad to visit your post.

  24. casino trực tuyến says

    This is the perfect trực tuyến It helped me a lot. If you have time, I hope you come to my site and share your opinions. Have a nice day.

  25. 789bet says

    Is the number 1 most popular online gambling website
    nline gambling website that gets numbers.

  26. DaviesObrien says

    Great this site and its information is very wang clothesThanks for sharing information such a great another people guide.

  27. georgenotfoundofficial says

    This is a very nice blog and learned more knowledge to read this post thanks for sharing this informative post.

  28. Dünyanın en pahalı telefonu says

    Dünyanın en pahalı telefonu

Some HTML is OK

or, reply to this post via trackback.