Skip to content


Op-Ed Should we let an unstable person have control of the nuclear arsenal? No, but that’s not the right question via Los Angeles Times

A growing chorus of politicians and national security experts have questioned whether it would be safe to have Donald Trump’s finger on the nuclear button. But are they asking the right question?

In an open letter, 50 leading Republican national security experts warned that Trump possesses “dangerous qualities in an individual who aspires to be president and commander in chief, with command of the U.S. nuclear arsenal.”

Or, as Hillary Clinton put it in her speech accepting the Democratic nomination: “A man you can bait with a tweet is not a man we can trust with nuclear weapons.”

Indeed, it would be very dangerous for an unstable, ill-informed person to have control of the nuclear arsenal.

Implicit in these admonitions, however, is the notion that it is OK to have a “normal” person in charge. In fact, many of Trump’s critics explicitly endorse the idea that nuclear weapons, in the right hands, constitute an effective deterrent to nuclear attack by other powers and are the best, even the ultimate, guarantors of our national security.

[…]

Unfortunately, the 2010 U.S. Nuclear Posture Review explicitly rejects the notion that the sole purpose of U.S. nuclear weapons is deterrence, and the U.S. has threatened to use them many times. Leading up to the 2003 invasion of Iraq, for instance, the U.S. refused to take the nuclear option off the table. Russian nuclear policy is even more dangerous, explicitly endorsing the early use of nuclear weapons in the event of a conventional war with NATO.

Pakistan has a similar nuclear doctrine that envisions the early first use of nuclear weapons if it should find itself in another war with India.

So the “normal” leaders of nuclear weapon states have already decided that under a variety of circumstances, nuclear weapons can and will be used.

[…]

Furthermore, studies have shown that we don’t need to have a full-scale nuclear war to destroy human civilization.  Even a very limited nuclear war, confined to one corner of the globe, would have disastrous consequences across the planet. The use of just 100 Hiroshima-sized bombs — less than 0.5% of the world’s nuclear arsenal — against targets in urban areas could loft enough soot into the upper atmosphere to disrupt climate worldwide, cutting food production and putting 2 billion people at risk of starvation.

For the nuclear weapon states, these are most inconvenient truths. They view their nuclear arsenals as tools to project national power that they do not want to give up. All nine are currently spending enormous sums on upgrading their arsenals, and they have shown a fierce opposition to the efforts of non-nuclear weapon states that wish to legally prohibit the possession of these weapons.

Commenting on the Cuban missile crisis, the most dangerous moment of the Cold War, former Defense Secretary Robert McNamara said, “It was luck that prevented nuclear war.” Nuclear weapons do not possess some magic power that keeps them from being used. We have survived the nuclear era so far because of an incredible string of luck, and we cannot expect that luck to last forever. Sooner or later, if we do not get rid of these weapons, they will be used and they will destroy us.

The right question for us to ask is: “Should anyone be able to press the nuclear button?” And the right answer is a resounding “No.”

Read more at Op-Ed Should we let an unstable person have control of the nuclear arsenal? No, but that’s not the right question 

Posted in *English.

Tagged with , .


21 Responses

Stay in touch with the conversation, subscribe to the RSS feed for comments on this post.

  1. Divyansh says

    आपके द्वारा दी गई जानकारी बहुत ही महत्वपूर्ण है। जानकारी साझा करने की लिए आपका बहुत बहुत धन्यवाद । Sarathi parivahan sewa की सभी जानकारी यहां देखें

  2. Rudrama says

    wow rally nice information i like it sir

  3. Sarkari Job Alert says

    Wow Good Information

  4. Up Free Smartphone Yojana says

    Rally Nice Information Up Free Smartphone Yojana

  5. Tiktok Video Downloader says

    TiktokVideoDownloader.Fun is an online tool helping you download videos from TikTok without a watermark. TiktokVideoDownloader.Fun is one of the most popular online video downloaders that can help you save videos from TikTok with the highest quality possible, in an MP4 file format with HD resolution. To find out how to use TikTok downloader, follow the instructions below. It is easy, you can save videos in three simple steps. TikTok video Downloader, is a fast and free way to download and save TikTok videos as MP4’s. Start by putting the TikTok video URL in the box below and click Go. It is one of the best TikTok Downloaders available online to download TikTok videos without a watermark. You are not required to install any software on your computer or mobile phone, all that you need is a TikTok video link, and all the processing is done on our side so you can be one click away from downloading videos to your devices.

  6. Tiktok Video Downloader says

    TiktokVideoDownloader.Fun is an online tool helping you download videos from TikTok without a watermark. TiktokVideoDownloader.Fun is one of the most popular online video downloaders that can help you save videos from TikTok with the highest quality possible, in an MP4 file format with HD resolution. To find out how to use TikTok downloader, follow the instructions below. It is easy, you can save videos in three simple steps. TikTok video Downloader, is a fast and free way to download and save TikTok videos as MP4’s. Start by putting the TikTok video URL in the box below and click Go. It is one of the best TikTok Downloaders available online to download TikTok videos without a watermark. You are not required to install any software on your computer or mobile phone, all that you need is a TikTok video link, and all the processing is done on our side so you can be one click away from downloading videos to your devices.

  7. Sarkari Exam says

    Thank you very much for sharing the information. The information provided by you is very important. Check here information related to Sarkari exam notification, admit card and government alerts for all government exams. 

  8. AMARJEET KUMAR says

    Thank you so much for sharing the information. This information which is provided by you very important and helped me also. I like this type of information and I want to say that visit here to know information related to Sarkari job updates, study material, admit card, results, and exam notification for all government exams.

  9. suraj shukla says

    very good information sir

  10. Rajat says

    all type hindi information

  11. bijli bill pay says

    Please enter your 12 digits Account no. provided in bill to view Bill & Pay Bill,. Account No : *. Image Verification : …

  12. UP free laptop yojana says

    nice information thanks a lot

  13. Ambedkar DBT Voucher Yojana Free Registration Online says

    check our website for information

  14. PM Kisan Yojana 2021 says

    nice post

  15. Sarkari Exam says

    Sarkari Exam info provides information about Sarkari Job in India, jobs’ notifications and updates, recruitment,Results, etc

    Sarkari Exam is an excellent source of Sarkari Naukri Sarkari Naukri, Rojgar Result, Sarkari Job for the candidates seeking employment from various Indian Government departments and organizations

  16. Sarkari Job says

    Sarkari Exam info provides information about Sarkari Job in India, jobs’ notifications and updates, recruitment,Results, etc

    Sarkari Exam is an excellent source of Sarkari Naukri Sarkari Naukri, Rojgar Result, Sarkari Job for the candidates seeking employment from various Indian Government departments and organizations

  17. Hot Videos says

    Sarkari Exam is to provide the latest information which includes vacancies in government sector or any other sectors across India and also provides employment news about Sarkari Exam like sarkari naukri, sarkari Job for various posts

  18. sarkariexam says

    a href=”https://sarkarijobfind.co/”>sarkarijobfind

  19. vishal says

    Pradhan Mantri Awas Yojana List 2021 and Online Form 2021 are Updated on its official website. candidates apply online for PMAY Gramin/Shahri (Urban/Rural) Registration Form 2021 before the final submission. for more details about PMAYG 2021, You need to visit the official website and check out carefully.

  20. abhinav says

    thank you very much.

  21. Indian Sarkari Escort says

    Sarkari Naukri is to provide the latest information which includes vacancies in government sector or any other sectors across India and also provides employment news about Sarkari Exam like sarkari naukri, sarkari Job for various posts



Some HTML is OK

or, reply to this post via trackback.