Skip to content

Nuclear Regulatory Commission Is Using Obviously Faulty Models to Pretend Crumbling Nuclear Reactors Are Safe via WashingtonsBlog

Ignoring Basic Engineering Science Puts Us All At Risk

Faulty assumptions by America’s financial regulators led to the 2008 crash … and many other disastrous results.

Similarly, America’s main nuclear regulator – the Nuclear Regulatory Commission – made numerous assumptions before Fukushima that turned out to be totally false. For example, the NRC wrongly assumed:

(1) The containment vessels in nuclear reactors always maintain their containment. In reality, Fukushima’s reactors lost all containment

(2) If radioactive gasses leak, they can only leak a maximum of 1% per day. In reality, Fukushima lost all of it’s radioactive gas every 8 hours (a 300% loss, since the leaking gas was replaced with newly-created radiation 3 times each day)

David Lochbaum – Director of the Nuclear Safety Project for the Union of Concerned Scientists, who worked as a nuclear engineer for nearly two decades, and has written numerous articles and reports on various aspects of nuclear safety and published two books – explained to Washington’s Blog some major erroneous assumptions that the NRC is making today about American nuclear plants:

The NRC has made some flawed assumptions. If you look at the chance of failure for a car, lightbulb or power plant, it’s governed by what’s called the “bathtub curve”. Specifically, the chance of failure is high early on due to material imperfections or assembly errors or the user just doesn’t know how to use the new “widget”. So there’s a break-in phase.

On the other side of the curve, the failure rate starts increasing again due to wear-out phase, due to aging, rusting, etc.

The NRC has been using that flat middle portion to justify reducing the frequency of inspections … even knowing that all of the plants are heading towards, if not already in, the wear-out phase, where the rate of failure starts increasing again.

So if you reduce the frequency based on the flat part of the curve, you may not be testing often enough, and things may break before you inspect and replace them.
Moreover, Lochbaum explained that the enormous power the government has to create incentives is leading to unsafe nuclear plants:

[Q] I understand that president Obama announced a nuclear renaissance in the U.S.

[A] This year alone we had 4 nuclear power reactors shut down due to unfavorable economics. A number of other plants that were proposed were cancelled due to costs. [Background.]

Many of the existing reactors have been operated with up to a 20% higher power level than they originally were built for or licensed for.

Many have already been that way and there’s also a few applicants that have submitted requests to the NRC to do upgrades at their plant.

In addition, more than three-quarters of existing reactors have sought and obtained 20 year extensions to the original 40-year operating lifetimes, and the others are in the process of doing so as well.

There’s now talk of going from 60 to 80 years. Nobody has done that yet, but there’s some talk of that.

The industry’s success in boosting operating output from existing plants and extending the life of the plants has been a major factor in preventing new reactors from being deployed, because you’ve pushed off the need for replacements.

[Q] Would the new reactors be safer in your view?

[A] Actually not, and it was actually the Federal government that prevented that, even though that was not their intent.

Back in 1957, the Federal government passed what is called the Price-Anderson Act, which provides federal liability insurance for plant owners and vendors.

Because of that – whether you’re the safest or the least safe reactor in the world – you pay the same insurance rate. In a more unrestricted marketplace, you have a safer car or a safer feature, your insurance premium is lower. So therefore a buyer can say “Yeah, it costs a little more up front, but I pay for that in 5 or 10 years down the road.

If you come up with a better mousetrap that costs more, the purchaser doesn’t get anything back.

So new reactors could be safer, because we’re smarter and we’ve learned more. But [federal insurance] makes it harder to sell, because the competitor down the road may not do that.

If a plant owner is looking at whether it would cost more to upgrade a 40 year old plant or to spend a little more to build a brand new reactor, the government is providing incentive for less safe things.

Read more.

Posted in *English.

Tagged with , , , .

6 Responses

Stay in touch with the conversation, subscribe to the RSS feed for comments on this post.

  1. Sbobet Soccer Gambling Official Site Easy 4D Jackpot Hundreds of Millions says

    Sbobet Odd-Even Football Gambling Game Very Best Quality

    Odd-even ball gambling games have the very best quality. You will not be able to make a profit without how to play odd-even soccer gambling on the official sbobet site properly and correctly. The system of this game is very similar to the odd-even lottery. However, from this game it is the number of goals that you will guess.

    That way the rules of the game are like on the official sbobet site, which means that you can play with two steps at once. Not only predicting matches, but you can also add up goals as well. This odd-even soccer gambling game, sbobet, is very much played because the potential for winning is very large. Come on, play now for free on the best official sbobet in Indonesia.

  2. Official Sbobet says

    The Official Site of Sbobet Soccer Gambling at the Best Agent 389Sports

    Maybe everyone already knows about this online sports betting which is often called the online sbobet judi bola site which is a place for betting by users who want to play this online ball.

    Moreover, this online sbobet judi bola site is managed by 389Sports where the online soccer gambling site is already very trusted because it has an official license from PAGCOR and BMM so it is very safe for those of you who want to play online judi bola. In addition, the bonuses are very abundant that you will get every day up to hundreds of millions of members vying to get it. Let’s register now, hopefully it will be your luck to get it on the best sbobet online judi bola site version 389Sports in Indonesia.

  3. Official Sbobet Wap says

    Enjoy Online Football Gambling Games on Trusted Sites

    All online soccer gambling lovers certainly have a place to bet in it so they can enjoy all the games on the situs judi bola. However, you must be able to choose the best and most trusted soccer gambling site to start a bet.

    One of the best and most trusted situs judi bola in Indonesia is the 389Sports site where this is the most complete situs judi bola agent that you can play young. The registration process is designed very sophisticatedly so that you can quickly place bets on the official 389Sports situs judi bola. Play now for free get a very abundant profit every day.

  4. Official Slot Pragmatic Play 389Sports says

    Keuntungan dalam bermain judi slot pragmatic play bisa Anda rasakan ketika sudah bermain di situs agen resmi pragmatic play di Indonesia salah satunya adalah 389Sports. Anda akan benar-benar mencapai titik dimana Anda apa yang diinginkan tercapai hanya modal bermain game slot pragmatic play di Smartphone kalian.

    Secara nyata bisa Anda jumpai bermain game slot online di pragmatic play sudah banyak yang sukses hampir di atas rata-rata yang bermain di agen resmi 389Sports sudah mendapatkan keuntungan yang sangat luar biasa setiap harinya.

    Tak susah apabila Anda berkeinginan bergabung dan bermain agar bisa menciptakan rekor tertinggi dalam mencapai kemenangan. Caranya sangat gampang kalian harus mempelajari tricknya terlebih dahulu bagaimana menciptakan kemenangan dalam bermain game slot pragmatic play yang bisa kalian temukan di Internet. Ayo gabung sekarang juga hasilkan uang secara mudah hingga ratusan juta setiap harinya di slot pragmatic play.

  5. Official Slot Joker388 says

    The Most Popular Joker388 Slot Gambling Site Lots of Bonuses at Trusted 389Sports Agents

    Now joker388 slot gambling is widely known in various circles of online slot gambling lovers throughout the world. Where the presence of the joker388 slot gambling site at a trusted agent 389Sports provides the best opportunity for you players to be able to make money in abundance because at the joker388 slot agent version 389Sports there are many bonuses.

    Already have official permission so it is very safe for you to bet on this joker388 slot. Very good service for 24 hours non-stop without stopping so that it can help in making this joker388 slot gambling bet. Come on, register for a joker388 slot account, you will get a new member bonus of 50% upon completion of registration and get bonuses of up to hundreds of millions in every game.

  6. tangkasnet says

    Ada banyak situs tangkasnet diluar sana tetapi tidak banyka yang benar benar bagus, hanya 389Sports saja yang memiliki kualitas yang tentu tidak dimiliki situs lainnya, maka dari itu tunggu apalagi dan langsung daftar dan bermain tangkasnet di situs 389Sports sekarang juga

Some HTML is OK

or, reply to this post via trackback.