Skip to content

For the NPT to work, plutonium has to go via the Bulletin of Atomic Scientists

By Victor GilinskyHenry Sokolski | March 15, 2021

The Nuclear Nonproliferation Treaty (NPT), whose tenth review conference is coming up in August, is in trouble, and not only because of the crescendo of complaints about the failure of the nuclear-armed states to implement nuclear disarmament. The treaty is threatened with irrelevancy because its controls have not kept up with the times. It was drafted over 50 years ago, when it was widely believed that nuclear energy represented the future and would soon take over the generation of electricity. Not surprisingly, countries put few treaty restrictions on access to technology or materials other than to impose international inspection, and even that was circumscribed. We now have a more realistic view of the dangers of access to fuels that are also nuclear explosives (plutonium and highly enriched uranium) and also of the limited economic utility of these fuels for powering reactors. If we want an effective NPT, we have to eliminate these dangerous materials from civilian nuclear power programs. Dealing with uranium enrichment is complicated because nuclear power plants use enriched uranium fuel, but that should not hold us back from eliminating the danger we can eliminate—plutonium.


It has since turned out that all of the “expert” thinking about plutonium-fueled fast breeder reactors taking over electricity production was wrong. Contrary to the projections of the 1960s, nuclear energy’s prospects are limited, uranium is not scarce, extracting plutonium from irradiated uranium fuel is hugely expensive, and the plutonium-fueled reactors are expensive to build, which eliminated the economic arguments for the so-called plutonium economy. This is now clear to all but messianic believers in nuclear energy.

But the vestiges of this technological archaism continue to animate national bureaucracies that deal with the NPT, including that of the US, and the IAEA, as well. Perhaps the most glaring examples of the residual attachment to plutonium is Japan, which accumulated an enormous stockpile of plutonium and China, which, like Japan, plans to open a large reprocessing plant to separate more for two large fast breeder reactors. The US Energy Department is planning an expensive fast reactor to test fuel (the Versatile Test Reactor) for a mythical future commercial generation of such reactors. These steps legitimate similar actions elsewhere and undermine effective nonproliferation controls.


At a more fundamental level, the United States needs to speak clearly to dispel the myth—one that still grips some NPT member countries—that nuclear power is an essential technology without which a country cannot consider itself as advanced. To get into the details would take us too far afield. But, as an indication of current nuclear prospects, consider the collapse of the highly vaunted “nuclear renaissance” at the beginning of this century that was to lead to construction of dozens of plants in the United States. US nuclear operators filed license applications for 31 large units. They ultimately canceled all but two, and those two are years behind schedule and already double the original cost, which led the original contractor, once proud Westinghouse, to file for bankruptcy.

America’s utility sector has been consistent on this score: It is not going to build any additional large nuclear reactors and doesn’t extract plutonium from used nuclear fuel. This message presented at the 2021 NPT Review Conference would help clear the decks for an honest assessment of what is needed for protection against access to nuclear weapons. If plutonium and reprocessing (its separation technology) are generally permissible, and only barred when worries arise in special cases like Iran, the NPT will ultimately undo itself.


Read more.

Posted in *English.

Tagged with , , , .

7 Responses

Stay in touch with the conversation, subscribe to the RSS feed for comments on this post.

  1. dark web links says

    Many people want to earn money through the Dark Net, but there is a lot of misinformation going around about how to make money through the Dark Net. The truth of the matter is that you cannot “make” money via links on the Dark Web. What you can do though, is to use the many links you can find to your advantage and get ranked higher in Google the natural way – with no artificial means.

  2. Garage Door Lock Phoenix AZ says

    Hi! Thanks for the great information you havr provided! You have touched on crucuial points!

  3. wps office activation code free says

    Itoo RailClone Pro Crack is the world-famous parametric modeling plugin for 3ds Max. It has a unique group approach to wealth creation and is quick and easy to learn. It differs from other parametric instruments in that it creates objects by scattering and manipulating the geometry created using standard modeling techniques.rhinoceros crack license key

  4. immunet crack says

    EaseUS Data Recovery Wizard Crack is the best accessible data recovery software to recover all lost data – recover lost data from hard drive, external hard drive, USB drive, memory card, digital cameras, cell phones, music, and other media, feedback, software crash, faulty hard drive, virus infection, distribution or other errors. easeus data recovery wizard crack

  5. pdf xchange editor crack says

    goldwave crack is a high-end professional digital audio editor that turns your computer or mobile device into a recording studio at your fingertips. GoldWave crack free download does everything from straightforward recording and editing to the most complex sound processing, restoration, enhancements, and conversions. 

  6. adobe illustrator crack says

    Very nice article is great for various design, web, and video applications anytime, anywhere. It is believed to be faster and smarter than any previous announcement. Adobe Illustrator Serial Number 2021 publication includes various new, improved tools and design tools that provide more ways to improve every aspect of your project.

  7. Ricky says

    Many people desire to earn cash on the Dark Net, however there is a lot of misunderstanding about how to generate money on the Dark Net. The reality is that you can’t “earn” money on the Dark Web by clicking on links. What you can do, however, is to take advantage of the numerous links available to you and rank higher in Google the natural manner — without the use of any artificial tactics. Mobile Bus Simulator Apk

Some HTML is OK

or, reply to this post via trackback.