Skip to content


South Korean Court Ruling Could Spur Nuclear-Power Plant Suits via The Wall Street Journal

Court Rules for Plaintiff Claiming Link Between Nuclear-Power Plant Radiation, Cancer

SEOUL–A South Korean court for the first time has ruled in favor of a plaintiff claiming a link between radiation from a nuclear power plant and cancer—a verdict that could trigger similar lawsuits in a country that depends heavily on nuclear power.

The Busan District Court ruled Friday in favor of a claim by Park Geum-sun, age 48, that her thyroid cancer was caused by radiation from six nuclear power plants located 7.7 kilometers from her house in Ichon-ri, Kijang County on the nation’s southeastern coast.

“She has lived within 10 kilometers of the plants for over 20 years and has thus been exposed to radiation for a long time. Other than the radiation from the nuclear reactors, there’s no clear reason for her cancer,” the court said in a written ruling.

The court ordered the operator of the nuclear plant, Korea Hydro & Nuclear Power Co., to pay Ms. Park 15 million won ($14,150) in compensation.

[…]

The decision is Korea’s first ruling on whether there is a relation between the location of nuclear plants and cancer in nearby residents, according to a court spokesman and Leem Jong-han, a professor of occupational medicine at Inha University.

Mr. Leem, who advised the judges in the case, said there is a high possibility that radiation from nuclear power plants caused an increase in the number of thyroid cancer patients in nearby Korean communities.

In its ruling, the court cited a government-commissioned study in 2011 that showed women living within five kilometers of nuclear plants had 2.5 times higher incidences of thyroid cancer than women living 30 kilometers or further from the plants.

The court also cited a study by Kijang County and a state-funded nuclear-power research institute which showed that of 3,031 Kijang County residents who had a medical checkup between July 2010 and December 2013, about 1.4%, or a total of 41 men and women, were found to have thyroid cancer. That compared with a 1.06% diagnosis rate for thyroid and other cancers among tens of thousands of citizens examined in Gangnam, Seoul, by Seoul National University Hospital in the same period, the documents said.

According to the Ministry of Health & Welfare, thyroid cancer topped the list of cancers found in South Korean women in 2011, with 114 cases out of 100,000 females surveyed. That compares with 12 cases in the same size survey in 1999, when the cancer was rated as the seventh most common malignant tumor among women. The ministry said the increase is partly due to increased detection from more-frequent medical checkups among women.

[…]

Public concerns over nuclear power have risen since Japan’s 2011 nuclear disaster in Fukushima, though there has been no fatal nuclear accident in South Korea since the country built its first commercial nuclear plant in 1978. In a nonbinding referendum earlier this month, for example, residents of the port city of Samcheok, north of Seoul, overwhelmingly voted against a government plan to build a nuclear-power plant in the area.

While the court ruled in favor of Ms. Park’s thyroid-cancer claim, it rejected a claim by her husband, Lee Jin-sup, that his rectal cancer and his 22-year-old son’s autism were also caused by long exposure to radiation from the nearby nuclear plant.

Read more at South Korean Court Ruling Could Spur Nuclear-Power Plant Suits

Posted in *English.

Tagged with , , , , , , .


2 Responses

Stay in touch with the conversation, subscribe to the RSS feed for comments on this post.

Continuing the Discussion

  1. NYTimes: Doctors want ban on thyroid cancer screenings — “A tsunami of thyroid cancer… Stop the diagnosis… We need to actively discourage early detection” — WSJ: Judge rules nuclear reactors causing thyroid cancers — Study: Fukushima-related linked to this post on 2014/11/08

    […] Wall St. Journal, Oct 21, 2014: A South Korean court for the first time has ruled in favor of a plaintiff claiming… thyroid cancer was caused by radiation from six nuclear power plants located [5 miles] from her house… “She has lived within 10 km of the plants for over 20 years and has thus been exposed to radiation for a long time. Other than the radiation from the nuclear reactors, there’s no clear reason for her cancer,” the court said… [A] government-commissioned study in 2011… showed women living within 5 km of nuclear plants had 2.5 times higher incidences of thyroid cancer… [In a study of the plaintiff's county by a] nuclear-power research institute… between July 2010 and December 2013, about 1.4%… were found to have thyroid cancer… in 2011 [women had] 114 cases out of 100,000 [0.11%]. […]

  2. WHY IS'NT MSM REPORTING ON THE escalating DANGERS of Radiation, UPDATED - Page 53 linked to this post on 2014/11/08

    […] of environmental exposures — or worse, uncertain effects of minor genetic alterations. Wall St. Journal, Oct 21, 2014: A South Korean court for the first time has ruled in favor of a plaintiff […]



Some HTML is OK

or, reply to this post via trackback.