Skip to content

Alex Wellerstein pulls back the curtain on nuclear secrecy via Bulletin of Atomic Scientists

By Susan D’Agostino | April 26, 2021

Historian Alex Wellerstein has thought about nuclear secrecy for a long time. He began writing his book, Restricted Data: The History of Nuclear Secrecy in the United States, when George W. Bush was president. He continued writing through the Obama and Trump administrations and released it during Biden’s first 100 days. Even so, the result seems current. US nuclear secrecy is a timeless topic, and Restricted Data informs the present as much as the past.

Restricted data” is a legal term relating to information about nuclear weapons, fissile material, and nuclear energy in the United States. The idea: The existential threat to humanity posed by the bomb is so singular that attempts to keep it secret require a special legal construction. But nuclear secrecy is more than legalese. It is “a bundle of many different ideas, desires, fears, hopes, activities, and institutional relationships that have changed over time, at times dramatically,” Wellerstein writes.


Susan D’Agostino: Did your lack of a clearance hinder your research?

Alex Wellerstein: You get real used to looking at deleted spots when you do any kind of work around nuclear weapons. And you get really used to your Freedom of Information Act [FOIA] requests being denied. With nukes there’s always going to be stuff deleted. But I was able to get some previously classified information through FOIA. There’s so much documentation out there that the problem was never not having access. I was drowning in paperwork for most of this book.

There are two reasons things might be still secret. One is it contains information that some classification guide out there says shouldn’t be released. And it’s going to be the judgment of whoever’s redacting it not to release it, based on the guide. Occasionally the things I want to know and the things that the censor cares about are the same, and then I have to work around that edge.

The other reason that it might be still classified is because nobody has taken the time to declassify it. This is a backlog problem. Only some small fraction of classified records have been reviewed for release. When I’m filing a FOIA request, I’m not expecting them to give me anything that would still be secret by any definition, but I’m expecting them to give me some things that nobody has bothered to request before and the agencies haven’t processed before. So, I did sometimes find new things this way.

Susan D’Agostino: In the case where the information you requested remained classified, how did you work around that edge?

Alex Wellerstein: Occasionally, they screw up the redaction, which gives you a glimpse behind the curtain. In one case, they sent me two different versions of the same classification guide in response to my FOIA request. But two different people reviewed these two identical versions, and they each redacted slightly differently. And if I combined their two versions, I sometimes had the full thing.

You learn that most of what they’re redacting is really boring. It’s not that they’re redacting, “Oh, we did some terrible thing.” It’s that they’re redacting that the size of this nozzle is 0.5 millimeters, and some other guy redacts the thing that says, “the size of this nozzle could also be 0.6 millimeters.” When you combine them together, you get the full story. But it’s usually not all that interesting a story.

I tried to understand how secrecy functions from the perspective of the person within the system—as opposed to how it looks on the outside, where it can look arbitrary, capricious, and foolish. On the inside, they’re given this impossible task of interpreting guidelines and then marking things up with absolute perfection. Their task is extremely technical. You can see the logic behind that, but it’s easy to say, “I don’t think the sum total of all of these tiny redactions is going to have much of an effect on proliferation one way or the other.”


In the ’90s, when they were trying to open things up, they brought those classification officials into a much wider conversation. They didn’t just have them talk with university scientists but with people who lived around production plants that might be polluting the environment or people downwind of nuclear testing. They had them talk with historians who do research on these topics and struggle to tell certain stories. If you could widen the perspective of the people within the classification system, it wouldn’t produce radical change overnight, but there might be more options. They could give slightly more information without giving away any secrets. They could say, “we really believe this could impact our nuclear proliferation or nuclear terrorism priorities.” People on the outside of these systems might not buy that, but they might feel like it was less arbitrary. It feels incredibly arbitrary when all you can get is, “no—national security.”


Read more.

Posted in *English.

Tagged with , .

25 Responses

Stay in touch with the conversation, subscribe to the RSS feed for comments on this post.

  1. Nebadita Maji says

    Well done for the idea on this subject. Absolutely going to search for more on this on the internet as it is one of the unique one. Its really great blog. I recommended to the other people. You may like this one
    Thanks for sharing this interesting article. 🙂

    Keep up the good work. Thank you again.

  2. Smart Kitchen Appliances Market says

    Nice blog, I really appreciate the hard efforts you would have taken while creating this informational blog. Smart Kitchen Appliances Market

  3. Sara says

    Sexy games ………

  4. sucre says

    วิธีดาวน์โหลดเกมส์ หรือเล่นผ่านเว็บง่ายๆโหลดฟรีได้เงินแน่นอน

  5. dark web links says

    Credit card fraud is a big problem on the Internet these days and getting your hands on credit without making a mistake is much easier said than done. The easiest way to get credit cards on the dark web is to look for a “pay once and get paid instantly” kind of site that will let you in by using your credit card number. Sadly, many of these sites are bogus or scams and they are quick to point this out by flashing up a red flag or two whenever you try to enter any information into their application form. This means that the only safe way of getting hold of how to get credit cards on the dark web is to use a site that requires a credit card number upfront before you can proceed. This way, you won’t have to worry about being caught out by anyone trying to scam you will be able to read the fine print so that you don’t get ripped off.

  6. Automotive Locksmith Services Tempe AZ says

    This is actually the kind of information I have been trying to find. Thank you for writing this information.

  7. Commercial Locksmith Services Tempe AZ says

    Thank you a bunch for sharing this with all of us you actually realize what you are talking about! Bookmarked. Please also seek advice from my site =). We could have a hyperlink change contract between us!

  8. Legal Wives Teleserye says

    Legal Wives GMA Telesery.

  9. Muds Management says

    Nice post, to engage in insurance business or start its daily operations an insurance web aggregator can help out to open an insurance company.

  10. pinoy teleserye says

    Watch Latest Pinoy Tambayan HD Pinoy Lambingan Shows Free Online

  11. Lambingan says

    Welcome to Pinoy Lambingan Teleserye, Watch your favorite Tambayan, Pinoy Tv Shows, Pinoy Teleserye, Pinoy Flix, Pinoy HD, Pinoy Channel Online.

  12. Lambingan says

    Welcome to Pinoy Lambingan Teleserye, Watch your favorite Tambayan, Pinoy Tv Shows, Pinoy Teleserye, Pinoy Flix, Pinoy HD, Pinoy Channel Online.

  13. Pinoy Lambingan says

    Thanks for nice post and information..sir..
    Pinoy Lambingan

  14. ivt bluesoleil crack says

    IVT Bluesoleil Crack is a popular all-in-one application that integrates some computers with Bluetooth. It has many uses and includes bluesoleil crack software, making it easy to focus on the paired device’s support. The handset is integrated with Bluetooth headsets, and the mobile phone will directly be incorporated into the model and architecture of this mid-range model. ivt bluesoleil crack

  15. adobe photoshop cc crack says

    webroot secureanywhere antivirus key crack license is the latest protection package for a much better security policy on your Windows computer. You can find impressive features integrated into this article. webroot key is a lightweight antivirus that protects your device from virus-like threats through cloud-based protection. free webroot keycode delivers cloud-based security technology.

  16. best slot says

    IF you like Casino online, we recommendbetflix The lucky person could be you.

  17. pdf xchange editor crack says

    ccleaner pro crack is a system optimization, privacy, and cleaning tool for Windows PC. Removes unused files from your system, allows Windows to run faster, and free up hard drive space. CCleaner Pro License Key also removes traces of your online activities, such as online history.

  18. adobe illustrator crack says

    Very nice article and a great for various design, web, and video applications anytime, anywhere. It is believed to be faster and smarter than any previous announcement. Adobe Illustrator Serial Number is publication includes various new, improved tools and design tools that provide more ways to improve every aspect of your project.

  19. Nigeria Trends says

    This is a lovely article and the trends continue

  20. Moses Bliss says

    Thank you a lot for sharing this with all of us you actually realize what you are talking about! Bookmarked. Please also seek advice from my site =). We could have a hyperlink change contract among us!

  21. avast premium crack says

    IObit Software Updater Pro Crack is a tool for checking and downloading up-to-date updates for installed programs.iobit software updater pro 4.3 key

  22. 에볼루션코리아 says

    Evolution Gaming Korea Service is open. [ 에볼루션코리아 ] The best evolution in Korea. evobench Evolution Korea offers a unique and unique experience, fun, and enjoyment. Good best evolution in Korea!

Some HTML is OK

or, reply to this post via trackback.