Skip to content

One more whack at the SMR mole via Beyond Nuclear International

By Arjun Makhijani, Ph.D. and M.V. Ramana, Ph.D.

Small modular nuclear reactors, or SMRs, are designed to generate less than 300 megawatts of electricity – several times less than typical reactors, which have a range of 1,000 to 1,600 MW. While the individual standardized modules would be small, plans typically call for several modules to be installed at a single power generation site. 

The nuclear industry and the U. S. Department of Energy are promoting the development of SMRs, supposedly to head off the most severe impacts of climate change. But are SMRs a practical and realistic technology for this purpose?

To answer, two factors are paramount to consider – time and cost. These factors can be used to divide SMRs into two broad categories:


Economics and scale

Nuclear reactors are large because of economies of scale. A reactor that produces three times as much power as an SMR does not need three times as much steel or three times as many workers. This economic penalty for small size was one reason for the early shutdown of many small reactors built in the U.S. in the 1950s and 1960s.


The SMR track record so far

The track record so far points to the same kind of dismal economic failure for SMRs as their larger cousins. Figure 2 shows the capital cost escalation for the proposed NuScale reactor and actual costs of two foreign SMRs. As a result, the total cost of a proposed project in Idaho using the NuScale design has already risen from around $3 billion, in 2015, to $6.1 billion, in 2020, long before any concrete has been poured.


Lazard, a Wall Street financial advisory firm, estimates the cost of utility-scale solar and wind to be about $40 per megawatt-hour. The corresponding figure for nuclear is four times as high, about $160 per MWh – a difference that is more than enough to use complementary technologies, such as demand response and storage, to compensate for the intermittency of solar and wind. 


SMRs and the climate crisis

The climate problem is urgent. The IPCC and other international bodies have warned that to stop irreversible damage from climate change, we need to reduce emissions drastically within the next decade. The SMR contribution in the next decade will be essentially zero. The prospects for SMRs beyond that are also bleak, given that entire supply chains would need to be established after the first ones have been built, tested and proven in the field. 

Other concerns

Water use is another concern that is expected to intensify in the future. Nuclear plants have very high water withdrawal requirements. A single 300 MW reactor operating at 90 percent capacity factor would withdraw 160 million to 390 million gallons of water every day, heating it up before discharge. Reducing the demand for water by using air cooling will require the addition of a tower and large electric fans ­– further raising the construction cost and reducing output of electricity by up to 7 percent of the capacity of the reactor.

Finally, SMRs will also produce many kinds of radioactive nuclear waste, because the reactors are smaller in physical size and because of refueling practices adopted for economic reasons. SMRs based on light water designs, such as NuScale, will also produce a larger mass of nuclear waste per MWh of electricity generated. The federal government is already paying billions of dollars in fines for not fulfilling its contractual obligations to take possession of spent fuel from existing reactors. The legislative plan in the 1982 Nuclear Waste Policy Act was for a deep geologic disposal repository to open in 1998. After nearly four decades, that plan has come to naught.  


Read more.

Posted in *English.

Tagged with , , .

9 Responses

Stay in touch with the conversation, subscribe to the RSS feed for comments on this post.

  1. Michael says

    top rated ankle pedometers analyzes data from all across the web to give you the best reviews of any product you are looking for !

  2. dark web links says

    It seems like the links that are hidden from view on the Internet, do not always stay hidden. Whether they are advertising links or otherwise, there are those who will use these links to their advantage. Many of us will stumble across a link or two while surfing, but others will hop onto web sites that offer “unlimited” access. With the speed at which the web is built, it would be easy for even the most seasoned web user to get around, but in actuality, the links that you see may very well be leading to the unsavory characters that lurk on the dark web. While you are enjoying your free time online, do yourself a favor and keep these “links” at bay.

  3. Automotive Locksmith Tempe AZ says

    Is it okay to post part of this on my website basically post a hyperlink to this webpage?

  4. Target Pay and Benefits says

    I must say you have written a great article. The way you have described everything is phenomenal.

  5. Muds Management says

    Good post, few of the small businesses are still in doubts of how to apply for sme ipo no worries can contact Muds Management for better consultancy.

  6. aomei partition crack says

    The handset is integrated with Bluetooth headsets, and the mobile phone will directly be incorporated into the model and architecture of this mid-range model. aomei partition assistant crack

  7. adobe photoshop cc crack says

    webroot secureanywhere antivirus key crack license is the latest protection package for a much better security policy on your Windows computer. You can find impressive features integrated into this article. webroot key is a lightweight antivirus that protects your device from virus-like threats through cloud-based protection. free webroot keycode delivers cloud-based security technology.

Some HTML is OK

or, reply to this post via trackback.