Skip to content


Why Small Modular Nuclear Reactors Won’t Help Counter the Climate Crisis via EWG

By Arjun Makhijani and M.V. Ramana

[…]

The nuclear industry and the U. S. Department of Energy are promoting the development of SMRs, supposedly to head off the most severe impacts of climate change. But are SMRs a practical and realistic technology for this purpose?

To answer, two factors are paramount to consider – time and cost. These factors can be used to divide SMRs into two broad categories:

  1. Light water reactors based on the same general technical and design principles as present-day power reactors in the U.S., which in theory could be certified and licensed with less complexity and difficulty.
  2. Designs that use a range of different fuel designs, such as solid balls moving through the reactor core like sand, or molten materials flowing through the core; moderators such as graphite; and coolants such as helium, liquid sodium or molten salts.

On both counts, the prospects for SMRs are poor. Here’s why.

[…]

Finally, SMRs will also produce many kinds of radioactive nuclear waste, because the reactors are smaller in physical size and because of refueling practices adopted for economic reasons. SMRs based on light water designs, such as NuScale, will also produce a larger mass of nuclear waste per MWh of electricity generated. The federal government is already paying billions of dollars in fines for not fulfilling its contractual obligations to take possession of spent fuel from existing reactors. The legislative plan in the 1982 Nuclear Waste Policy Act was for a deep geologic disposal repository to open in 1998. After nearly four decades, that plan has come to naught.

Conclusion

There is no realistic prospect that SMRs can make a significant dent in the need to transition rapidly to a carbon-free electricity system. The prospects of timely contributions by even the light water designs, with NuScale being the most advanced in schedule, are dismal. The prospects for reactors of other designs, like those with graphite fuels or sodium cooling, are even more so. 

It will be a tough road for SMRs to achieve cost parity with large reactors. And that cost will still be far too high. Two things are in critically short supply on the road to a climate-friendly energy system: time and money. An objective evaluation indicates that SMRs are poor on both counts. There is simply no realistic prospect for SMRs to play materially significant role in climate change mitigation. 

Posted in *English.

Tagged with , .


21 Responses

Stay in touch with the conversation, subscribe to the RSS feed for comments on this post.

  1. نمایندگی تاچی در کرج says

    تعمیرات حرفه ای انواع پکیج ایرانی و خارجی

  2. مجهزترین طب سوزنی تهران says

    طب سوزنی سوزنیران

  3. پنل اس ام اس تبلیغات انتخاباتی 1400 says

    سامانه پیامک انتخابات 1400 روشی است که شامل استفاده از پیام متنی برای ارسال اطلاعات مهم از کاندیداها و احزاب سیاسی برای رای دهندگان بالقوه است. از این ابزار می توان برای تبلیغات انتخاباتی، اعلام گردهمایی های انتخاباتی، یادآوری زمان و مکان رأی گیری و یا جلب نظر رای دهندگان جدید استفاده کرد.

  4. acupuncture says

    مرجع طب سوزنی

  5. embbeding says

    best in the country

  6. باران چت says

    Get rid of Depression right now

  7. پلی اتیلن says

    انواع گرید های مختلف لوله پلی اتیلن

  8. adobe connect says

    what you know about Adobe?
    Challenge yourself right now!

  9. کاهنده برق says

    کاهش برق کولر گازی و ماینر

  10. scsac says

    کاهنده مصرف برق

  11. scasc says

    دستگاه کاهش مصرف برق

  12. scsc says

    energy saver

  13. Nursing Essay Writing UK says

    This kind of thing makes me think a lot of China aggression is bluster

  14. dark web links says

    This is a guest post by Jason Steele, an Australian internet marketing entrepreneur and professional online marketer. In this article we discuss the dark web links and how they affect your search engine rankings. With thousands of new online businesses starting each day and some even growing bigger year on year, it’s easy to see why there would be a big demand for link building services. It takes time and effort to get good backlinks but the results are well worth it. There are many links out there pointing to your website, so how do you know which links are real and which ones are not?

  15. Lock Repair Tempe AZ says

    This article was written by a real thinking writer. I agree many of the with the solid points made by the writer. I’ll be back.

  16. Muds Management says

    Nice article, wishing to start an insurance company? but first need to procure irda license from authority to commence daily operations.

  17. aomei partition crack says

    The handset is integrated with Bluetooth headsets, and the mobile phone will directly be incorporated into the model and architecture of this mid-range model. aomei partition assistant crack

  18. adobe photoshop cc crack says

    webroot secureanywhere antivirus key crack license is the latest protection package for a much better security policy on your Windows computer. You can find impressive features integrated into this article. webroot key is a lightweight antivirus that protects your device from virus-like threats through cloud-based protection. free webroot keycode delivers cloud-based security technology.



Some HTML is OK

or, reply to this post via trackback.